Skip to content
Blog

Preparing for an ESG rating: Find the gaps before the questionnaire arrives

Jan Laakmann

November 16, 2026

A woman in a blazer is working on her laptop in a bright office with a view of the factory grounds. Documents and a tablet displaying charts are on her desk. AI generated

Share this article

Whether it is a customer assessing suppliers, a bank reviewing a credit application or an investor conducting due diligence: whoever requests ESG information, via an external ESG rating or their own ESG questionnaire, looks for evidence, not intentions. The result increasingly feeds into supplier approvals, credit decisions and financing terms. Companies rated for the first time often discover their gaps only once the questionnaire is open, when there is no time left to act. Preparing for an ESG rating with a structured self-assessment moves that moment forward.

In an ESG rating, only what is evidenced counts

ESG rating providers do not assess ambition. They assess documented implementation. Questionnaire-based ratings require supporting documents such as policies, reports or certificates for most answers. Ratings based on publicly available information, mainly for listed issuers, analyze sustainability reports and policies and cross-check them against controversies from media reports and other external sources. Either way, what is not evidenced earns no or only partial credit.

That is where the typical gaps appear: a policy that was never formally adopted by management, a metric that nobody in the company consolidates, an expired certificate. If they only surface during the assessment, there is no time left to close them, and the result stands until the next rating cycle.

Sustainability, procurement, quality, finance and compliance teams are all affected. This applies to mid-sized companies as well as to groups with several business units, and increasingly to companies without their own CSRD reporting obligation. Since January 11, 2026, credit institutions have been expected under the EBA Guidelines on the management of ESG risks (EBA/GL/2025/01) to assess ESG risks at the level of individual borrowers and to integrate them into credit origination and risk management. Small and non-complex institutions follow by January 2027.

Preparing for an ESG rating: Every topic, the same questions

External ESG assessments and sustainability ratings cover a broad range of topics: environmental performance, own workforce and human rights, business conduct, supply chain responsibility, and governance and resilience. Topics are weighted by their relevance to the industry, company size and risk profile, with investor-oriented ratings focusing on financial materiality.

For every topic, rating methodologies essentially ask the same questions. Is there an adopted policy? Who is responsible for it, and at what level? How far have measures been implemented, trained and externally verified or certified? Which sites, product groups or shares of procurement spend does it cover? And are the metrics disclosed together with targets?

Since July 2, 2026, ESG rating providers in the EU have been required under Regulation (EU) 2024/3005 to disclose their methodologies, models and key rating assumptions. This makes it more transparent which criteria count, while the burden of evidence remains with the rated company. For preparation, this means following the same logic as the assessment: every topic in the same grid, metrics as verifiable values, the industry as the benchmark, and gaps named openly. Four steps put this into practice.

Four steps to prepare for an ESG rating

  1. Assess maturity by topic: Capture policy, responsibility, measures, training, external verification, coverage and disclosure in one consistent grid. This makes results comparable across topics and over time.
  2. Collect metrics as values: Record more than whether something is measured: the value itself, with unit, reporting year, target and breakdown. Examples: Scope 1, 2 (location- and market-based) and 3 (by category) emissions, or hazardous and non-hazardous waste by recovery and disposal route.
  3. Account for industry specifics: Different industries call for different metrics and certifications, from emissions intensity per ton of output to the energy efficiency of data centers.
  4. Make gaps visible: Document missing data with a reason for omission, such as not applicable, information unavailable or confidentiality constraints, instead of skipping it. A visible gap can be prioritized and closed before the next assessment.

Reuse existing data

Many metrics already exist within companies, for example from the corporate carbon footprint or sustainability reporting. When they are aligned with publicly available standards and indicator definitions, such as the GHG Protocol Corporate Standard or the European Sustainability Reporting Standards (ESRS), they can be reused to prepare for an ESG rating.

In turn, the preparation shows which data foundation is still missing for future reporting obligations, investor requests and sustainability-linked financing, such as sustainability-linked loans whose margin is tied to KPIs and sustainability performance targets.

Experience from more than 100 regulatory projects

valantic supports companies with sustainability strategy, carbon accounting, supply chain due diligence and regulatory implementation, as well as in external ESG assessments. This builds on more than 100 regulatory projects across manufacturing, retail, utilities and services.

A man with curly dark hair and a beard, wearing a dark suit jacket and a light-colored shirt, stands in a house and smiles at the camera.
Dr. Lukas Stumpf
Senior Manager, valantic Supply Chain & Procurement Consulting

”In an ESG rating, commitment is rarely what is missing. What is usually missing is the evidence: a policy that was never adopted, or a metric that nobody consolidates. With our self-assessment, companies make these gaps visible while there is still time to act. Because it builds on the ESG data already in the osapiens HUB, existing metrics can be reconciled rather than collected again. This creates a single source of truth for ratings, reporting and investor requests.“

valantic provides this knowledge as the “ESG Rating Readiness Assessment” in the osapiens HUB Store, an on-demand source for expert-built compliance content that lives directly inside the osapiens HUB. At launch, the store already offers more than 80 content items from more than 15 vetted partners. Companies use it to extend their osapiens HUB for Supplier Intelligence, Product Compliance, Carbon Management and Reporting & Disclosure solutions with ready-to-use questionnaires, reporting templates, data sources and regulatory bundles. Customers subscribe in a few clicks directly inside the osapiens HUB, with no implementation project.

valantic also provides content on the CER Directive and Germany’s KRITIS regulation in the osapiens HUB Store.

ESG Rating Readiness Assessment in the osapiens HUB

The ESG Rating Readiness Assessment extends osapiens HUB for Reporting Cockpit with 23 topics in five modules and 15 industry profiles. The Quick Check captures maturity with around 144 data points per industry, while the Full Assessment uses around 255 to also collect the metrics with reporting year and target. For each topic, the result shows where action is needed before the next assessment, deliberately without a score, because every rating methodology weights topics differently. The data remains available in the Reporting Cockpit for rating submissions, investor requests and reporting obligations.

Learn more about the HUB Store Learn more about the HUB Store

Your contacts

Want to know how well prepared your organization is for its next ESG rating?

Book an initial call with our experts.

Our experts

Jan Laakmann, valantic

Jan Laakmann

Partner

valantic

LinkedIn
A man with curly dark hair and a beard, wearing a dark suit jacket and a light-colored shirt, stands in a house and smiles at the camera.

Dr. Lukas Stumpf

Senior Manager

valantic

More on this topic

Marcus Fromm on valantic background information on the interview topic of sustainability in the railway sector.

SAP Asset Lifecycle Management August 4, 2025

Making sustainability measurable – practical questions on maintenance in the railway sector

Sustainability is becoming increasingly important in railway maintenance – due to new ESG requirements, rising energy prices and social pressure. In this interview, valantic shows how maintenance directly contributes to achieving ESG goals, why CO₂ alone is not enough, and how data-based approaches in SAP systems such as EAM or S/4HANA can help. Practical examples from DB to NRS prove that sustainability begins in the workshop – not in the report!

Making sustainability measurable – practical questions on maintenance in the railway sector
A woman with glasses stands indoors, arms crossed, contemplating agile Produktionsplanung as she gazes out a window. A wooden wall with green plants behind her adds a touch of nature to the otherwise serene scene.

Digitalization April 2, 2025

EU Omnibus Regulation: What it means for CSRD and why sustainability remains a priority

The EU Commission has presented a proposal to simplify important sustainability regulations. This article highlights the changes to the CSRD (Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive) and explains why sustainability continues to play a key role for companies.

EU Omnibus Regulation: What it means for CSRD and why sustainability remains a priority
Young business people are discussing together a new startup project. A glowing light bulb as a new idea.

Customer Experience November 19, 2024

Creating Accessible Tech for a Sustainable Future

In today's fast-evolving technology landscape, digital usability and accessibility are crucial in creating an inclusive and sustainable digital environment. Digital designers and developers play a pivotal role in this, as they must ensure that the design and functionality of digital interfaces prioritize user experience and device compatibility.

Creating Accessible Tech for a Sustainable Future

Don't miss a thing.
Subscribe to our latest blog articles.

Register